The effect of tightening torque and washer size on the performance of basalt natural fiber composite joints was investigated experimentally. It was found that washer size is the main design driver in controlling the out-of-plane behavior of the joint. Specifically, there was a 36.5 increase in the 0.2 offset strength when the torque was increased for small washer configurations, whereas a 42 increase was observed when the torque was increased for large washer configurations. Moreover, the ultimate bearing strength also showed an improvement under the combined effect of washer size and tightening torque. Additionally, damage onset and failure mechanisms of the bolted joint were investigated using optical microscopy. The morphological observations indicated excessive crushing for large washer configurations. It is postulated that bearing performance could be improved by choosing appropriate washer size and tightening torque. © 2021 Taylor & Francis.